Key West, Florida, is renowned for its vibrant culture, stunning sunsets, and, of course, its incredible food scene. From fresh seafood to Cuban-inspired dishes, there’s something to tantalize every palate. Here’s a guide to the 10 best places to eat in Key West.
1. Blue Heaven
Location: 729 Thomas Street
Blue Heaven is a quintessential Key West eatery known for its eclectic atmosphere and delicious brunch. Enjoy dining under a canopy of tropical trees with roaming chickens and cats. Must-try dishes include the lobster Benedict and their signature Key lime pie.
2. Louie’s Backyard
Location: 700 Waddell Avenue
For a dining experience with a view, Louie’s Backyard offers stunning oceanfront scenery paired with a sophisticated menu. The restaurant specializes in Caribbean-American cuisine. Be sure to try the Bahamian Conch Chowder and their freshly caught seafood.
3. Santiago’s Bodega
Location: 207 Petronia Street
Santiago’s Bodega is a cozy tapas restaurant perfect for sharing small plates with friends. Their diverse menu includes delicacies like beef tenderloin with blue cheese butter and bacon-wrapped dates. The laid-back ambiance and extensive wine list make it a local favorite.
4. El Siboney
Location: 900 Catherine Street
For authentic Cuban cuisine, El Siboney is a must-visit. This family-owned restaurant serves hearty portions of traditional dishes like Ropa Vieja, Cuban sandwiches, and delicious flan for dessert. The casual atmosphere and friendly service enhance the dining experience.
5. Garbo’s Grill
Location: 409 Caroline Street
Garbo’s Grill is a food truck turned local legend. Known for its fusion cuisine, Garbo’s offers a variety of unique dishes such as Korean BBQ tacos and mango hot dogs. The quirky, laid-back setting and flavorful food keep customers coming back.
6. Eaton Street Seafood Market & Restaurant
Location: 801 Eaton Street
For the freshest seafood in town, Eaton Street Seafood Market is the place to go. You can choose your seafood from the market and have it cooked to order. Highlights include their lobster roll, conch fritters, and grilled fish sandwiches.
7. The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
Location: 1100 Packer Street
The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. is a cozy bistro offering a mix of American classics and Caribbean flavors. Signature dishes include their lobster mac and cheese and the tropical tuna ceviche. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes it perfect for a romantic dinner.
8. Latitudes
Location: 245 Front Street (Sunset Key)
Latitudes, located on Sunset Key, offers a luxurious dining experience with breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico. Accessible only by boat, this upscale restaurant serves gourmet cuisine with highlights like the Yellowtail Snapper and the Key Lime Tart.
9. Café Marquesa
Location: 600 Fleming Street
Café Marquesa, situated in the heart of Old Town, offers a fine dining experience with an emphasis on fresh, local ingredients. The menu features a blend of contemporary American and seafood dishes, such as seared scallops and rack of lamb.
10. Pepe’s Café
Location: 806 Caroline Street
Established in 1909, Pepe’s Café is the oldest restaurant in Key West, offering a historic charm and a hearty menu. Known for its breakfast and brunch, you can enjoy classics like homemade corned beef hash and fresh-squeezed orange juice mimosas.
Final Thoughts
Key West’s culinary scene is as diverse and vibrant as the island itself. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual meal or an upscale dining experience, the island offers something for every taste. Make sure to visit these top 10 spots for an unforgettable gastronomic adventure in Key West, Florida. Bon appétit!
